Presumed Guilt /Acting like you are already guilty

An officer may tell you that they already know you did something or ask questions that assume you did. Instead of asking, “Did you do it?” they might ask, “Why did you do it?” or “What made you do it?”

They may also challenge your answers, interrupt your denials, or repeatedly tell you that they do not believe your explanation. After hearing the same accusation again and again, it can become harder to keep explaining yourself or feel like anyone will believe you.

This can be especially difficult for young people, who may be more likely to trust that an adult or authority figure must have a good reason for being so sure. The pressure can make someone feel like denying it is pointless, even if they know they did not do what they are being accused of.

Remember: An officer sounding certain does not mean that you have to agree with them or change your answer. If something they say is not true, you do not have to accept it as true.